Auto Body & Collision Repair Shops in Amherst, NY

Collision repair in Amherst, New York

3 auto body and collision repair shops in Amherst are listed on this page. 2 of them hold a Google rating of 4.5 stars or better, and together the shops on this page have collected 1,796 reviews. Ratings come straight from Google reviews, so the order reflects what local customers reported — not paid placement or insurer steering.

The highest-rated established shop in Amherst is Amherst Automotive LLC at 5.0 stars from 404 reviews, while CARSTAR Collision of Amherst has the deepest review history with 1,225 reviews.

What body work typically costs

Our collision repair cost guides break down what each repair should cost — dent repair, scratches, bumpers, hail damage, and paint work — including what drives the price and when an insurance claim beats paying cash. Knowing the going rate before you call makes it far easier to judge whether an estimate in Amherst is fair.

Getting an estimate

Every shop page in this directory includes a free photo estimate: upload a few pictures of the damage and get a preliminary repair figure back in minutes, before you drive anywhere. It is a fast way to sanity-check a quote you have already been given, or to walk into a Amherst shop knowing roughly what the job should cost. The shop still confirms the final number in person — a written estimate always requires an inspection.