Auto Body & Collision Repair Shops in Evansville, WI

3 top collision repair shops in Evansville.

3 collision repair shops in Evansville

Ranked by rating and review count

Also serving Evansville

Nearby collision repair shops, ordered by distance from Evansville.

Auto Magic Accessories Ltd storefront

Auto Magic Accessories Ltd

4.723 reviews

265 S River St · 0.3 mi away

(608) 756-2886

City CARSTAR storefront

City CARSTAR

4.9383 reviews

14 N Locust St · 0.6 mi away

(608) 752-1768

National Coatings & Supplies (formerly Body Shop Supply) storefront

National Coatings & Supplies (formerly Body Shop Supply)

4.441 reviews

815 W Court St · 0.6 mi away

(608) 754-6442

Arnold Automotive, LLC storefront

Arnold Automotive, LLC

4.823 reviews

612 N Main St · 0.7 mi away

(608) 931-9118

Andy's Auto Repair storefront

Andy's Auto Repair

4.222 reviews

1515 E Racine St · 0.8 mi away

(608) 756-1614

The Dent Co storefront

The Dent Co

555 S Pearl St #5010 · 1.1 mi away

(608) 728-7795

Utzig CARSTAR Collision Service storefront

Utzig CARSTAR Collision Service

4.9621 reviews

1715 W Court St · 1.2 mi away

(608) 752-7727

Dave's Auto Service Inc storefront

Dave's Auto Service Inc

4.865 reviews

1806 W Court St · 1.2 mi away

(608) 757-0996

Schoonover's Automotive Service Center

4.641 reviews

1111 Harold Ave · 1.3 mi away

(608) 754-2417

Economy Auto Body Shop storefront

Economy Auto Body Shop

5.010 reviews

908 Sharon Rd · 1.4 mi away

(608) 756-1954

Firestone Complete Auto Care storefront

Firestone Complete Auto Care

4.4501 reviews

1222 Creston Park Dr · 1.4 mi away

(608) 352-6453

Elite Auto Glass - Janesville storefront

Elite Auto Glass - Janesville

4.8182 reviews

910 Sharon Rd · 1.4 mi away

(608) 201-8304

3 shops on this map · numbers match the list

Collision repair in Evansville, Wisconsin

3 auto body and collision repair shops in Evansville are listed on this page. 1 of them holds a Google rating of 4.5 stars or better, and together the shops on this page have collected 63 reviews. The ratings here are Google's own review scores. Nobody pays to rank higher on this page, and no insurer decides the order.

What body work typically costs

Most surprises at the counter come from not knowing the range beforehand, so it is worth a minute before you call a Evansville shop. Paintless dent repair usually runs $75–$350 while the paint is intact; once the paint is cracked or the metal is creased, the same dent becomes $350–$1,500 or more of conventional body work. Bumper work spans $150–$600 for scuffs and $500–$2,500+ for a full replacement once parking sensors and cameras are involved, and hail damage across a whole vehicle typically lands between $750 and $8,000.

Our collision repair cost guides break down each repair in detail — dent repair, scratches, bumpers, hail damage, and paint work — including what drives the price and when an insurance claim beats paying cash.

Choosing a shop in Evansville

Once you have two or three candidates, a few questions separate them quickly:

  • Get more than one estimate. Quotes for the same damage routinely differ by hundreds of dollars, and a second opinion costs you nothing.
  • Ask what the warranty covers. Most reputable shops guarantee their paint and workmanship — get the length and what voids it in writing.
  • Settle the parts question up front. OEM, aftermarket, and used parts carry very different prices and fitment; ask which the estimate assumes.
  • Check the insurance angle. You are free to pick your own shop regardless of what an insurer suggests — but confirm the shop bills your carrier directly if you are filing a claim.
  • Ask about ADAS calibration. If your car has lane-keep, blind-spot, or automatic braking, cameras and radar often need recalibrating after body or glass work.

Getting an estimate

Every shop page in this directory includes a free photo estimate: upload a few pictures of the damage and get a preliminary repair figure back in minutes, before you drive anywhere. It is a fast way to sanity-check a quote you have already been given, or to walk into a Evansville shop knowing roughly what the job should cost. The shop still confirms the final number in person — a written estimate always requires an inspection.