Auto Repair, Body Shops & Specialists in New Cumberland, PA

4 automotive shops in New Cumberland. Compare listed specialties before contacting a business.

4 automotive shops in New Cumberland

Ranked by rating and review count

Labels reflect published business categories, not a guarantee of service. Confirm the specific repair with the shop.

  • CARSTAR Fred Beans of New Cumberland storefront1

    CARSTAR Fred Beans of New Cumberland

    4.871 reviews

    100 15th St · 2.6 mi away

    (717) 774-7346

    Auto Body Shop

    Listed: Auto body & collision · General auto repair

  • Leahy's Auto Repair storefront2

    Leahy's Auto Repair

    4.7229 reviews

    121 8th St · 3.0 mi away

    (717) 731-9648

    Auto Repair Shop

    Listed: General auto repair · Wheel alignment · Brake repair · Oil changes & lubrication · Vehicle inspections & emissions

  • Benyou's Auto Body & Sons storefront3

    Benyou's Auto Body & Sons

    4.621 reviews

    407 Pleasant View Rd · 6.0 mi away

    (717) 938-6577

    Auto Body Shop

    Listed: Auto body & collision · General auto repair · Vehicle inspections & emissions

  • Rippin' Rides storefront4

    Rippin' Rides

    4.5123 reviews

    909 Bridge St · 3.0 mi away

    (717) 770-1177

    Auto Repair Shop

    Listed: General auto repair · Motorcycle repair

Also serving New Cumberland

Nearby automotive shops, ordered by distance from New Cumberland.

Caliber Collision storefront

Caliber Collision

4.741 reviews

5024 Simpson Ferry Rd · 5.9 mi away

(223) 285-5380

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision · Dent repair · Auto painting · General auto repair · Vehicle restoration

Browns Auto Body Werks storefront

Browns Auto Body Werks

4.899 reviews

5030 Arthur Ave · 6.0 mi away

(717) 691-3679

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision

CARSTAR Fred Beans Mechanicsburg storefront

CARSTAR Fred Beans Mechanicsburg

4.8718 reviews

6302 Carlisle Pike · 6.4 mi away

(717) 766-8758

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision

Bakers Auto Body storefront

Bakers Auto Body

4.88 reviews

714 Allegheny St · 7.1 mi away

(717) 921-8748

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision

Keystone Auto Armory storefront

Keystone Auto Armory

699 E Simpson St · 7.1 mi away

(717) 884-5312

Auto Repair Shop

Listed: General auto repair

Hyser's Service Center storefront

Hyser's Service Center

5.0127 reviews

615 Leona St · 7.1 mi away

(717) 697-4601

Auto Repair Shop

Listed: General auto repair

Autobodies by Lucas storefront

Autobodies by Lucas

4.7179 reviews

526 E Main St · 7.2 mi away

(717) 766-0641

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision

Mike's Shop storefront

Mike's Shop

4.610 reviews

419 E Main St · 7.2 mi away

(717) 795-7031

Auto Repair Shop

Listed: General auto repair

Hampden Automotive and Towing Inc storefront

Hampden Automotive and Towing Inc

4.8284 reviews

200 N Walnut St · 7.4 mi away

(717) 620-8817

Auto Repair Shop

Listed: General auto repair · Tires · Brake repair · Exhaust & mufflers · Vehicle inspections & emissions · Towing & roadside assistance

Maaco Auto Body Shop & Painting storefront

Maaco Auto Body Shop & Painting

4.6333 reviews

6498 Carlisle Pike · 7.5 mi away

(717) 516-7312

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision · Dent repair · Auto painting

Miller's Enthusiast Auto Works storefront

Miller's Enthusiast Auto Works

4.939 reviews

114 E Main St · 7.6 mi away

(717) 708-1842

Auto Repair Shop

Listed: General auto repair

CARSTAR at Cramer's Middletown storefront

CARSTAR at Cramer's Middletown

4.579 reviews

1958 W Harrisburg Pike · 8.2 mi away

(717) 944-4020

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision

4 shops on this map · numbers match the list

Automotive shops in New Cumberland, Pennsylvania

4 automotive shops in New Cumberland are listed on this page. 4 of them hold a Google rating of 4.5 stars or better, and together the shops on this page have collected 444 reviews. Ratings come straight from Google reviews, so the order reflects what local customers reported — not paid placement or insurer steering.

The highest-rated established shop in New Cumberland is CARSTAR Fred Beans of New Cumberland at 4.8 stars from 71 reviews, while Leahy's Auto Repair has the deepest review history with 229 reviews.

What body work typically costs

Our collision repair cost guides break down what each repair should cost — dent repair, scratches, bumpers, hail damage, and paint work — including what drives the price and when an insurance claim beats paying cash. Knowing the going rate before you call makes it far easier to judge whether an estimate in New Cumberland is fair.

Getting an estimate

For body and cosmetic damage, eligible shop pages offer a $4.99 preliminary photo report. This is not a mechanical diagnosis or a quote for tires, transmissions or drivetrain work. For those services, contact the business about an inspection and written estimate. Any preliminary bodywork figure also needs confirmation by the shop.