Auto Body & Collision Repair Shops in Shirley, NY

1 top collision repair shop in Shirley.

1 collision repair shop in Shirley

Ranked by rating and review count

Also serving Shirley

Nearby collision repair shops, ordered by distance from Shirley.

Shirley Auto Body storefront

Shirley Auto Body

4.5192 reviews

1272 Montauk Hwy · 0.9 mi away

(631) 281-4300

South Shore Auto Collision storefront

South Shore Auto Collision

4.8173 reviews

624 North St · 2.3 mi away

(631) 924-1560

Crossroads Body & Fender Works storefront

Crossroads Body & Fender Works

5.026 reviews

364 Ryerson Ave · 5.4 mi away

(631) 878-6886

Beach Auto Collision storefront

Beach Auto Collision

5.0341 reviews

114 Old Riverhead Rd · 11.7 mi away

(631) 998-3510

North Fork Auto Body storefront

North Fork Auto Body

4.986 reviews

26 Edgar Ave · 16.0 mi away

(631) 722-4290

1 shop on this map · numbers match the list

Collision repair in Shirley, New York

One auto body shop in Shirley is listed on this page. It holds a 5.0-star Google rating from 58 reviews. Ratings come straight from Google reviews, so the order reflects what local customers reported — not paid placement or insurer steering.

What body work typically costs

Our collision repair cost guides break down what each repair should cost — dent repair, scratches, bumpers, hail damage, and paint work — including what drives the price and when an insurance claim beats paying cash. Knowing the going rate before you call makes it far easier to judge whether an estimate in Shirley is fair.

Getting an estimate

Every shop page in this directory offers a $14.99 photo report: upload a few pictures of the damage and get a preliminary repair figure back in minutes, before you drive anywhere. The one-time report is a fast way to sanity-check a quote you have already been given, or to walk into a Shirley shop knowing roughly what the job should cost. The shop still confirms the final number in person — a written estimate always requires an inspection.