Auto Repair, Body Shops & Specialists in Pine Island, NY

1 automotive shop in Pine Island. Compare listed specialties before contacting a business.

1 automotive shop in Pine Island

Ranked by rating and review count

Labels reflect published business categories, not a guarantee of service. Confirm the specific repair with the shop.

Also serving Pine Island

Nearby automotive shops, ordered by distance from Pine Island.

Green's Auto Body LLC storefront

Green's Auto Body LLC

4.759 reviews

2755 US-6 · 6.5 mi away

(845) 355-1016

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision

Eason' Auto Body Inc storefront

Eason' Auto Body Inc

4.940 reviews

434 County Rd 56 · 7.7 mi away

(845) 342-2488

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision

Caliber Collision storefront

Caliber Collision

4.7494 reviews

28 Cannon Hill Dr · 8.5 mi away

(845) 374-2113

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision · Dent repair · Auto painting · General auto repair · Vehicle restoration

Mount Hope Auto Body and Service Center storefront

Mount Hope Auto Body and Service Center

4.942 reviews

2595 Mt Hope Rd · 11.8 mi away

(845) 412-6071

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision · General auto repair · Towing & roadside assistance

Ulee's Truck & Auto Repair storefront

Ulee's Truck & Auto Repair

4.9127 reviews

9 State St · 12.5 mi away

(845) 386-4773

Auto Repair Shop

Listed: General auto repair

J's Auto Body & Collision storefront

J's Auto Body & Collision

5.088 reviews

33 Railroad Ave · 23.5 mi away

(845) 401-6522

Auto Body Shop

Listed: Auto body & collision

1 shop on this map · numbers match the list

Automotive shops in Pine Island, New York

One automotive business in Pine Island is listed on this page. It holds a 4.8-star Google rating from 58 reviews. Ratings come straight from Google reviews, so the order reflects what local customers reported — not paid placement or insurer steering.

What body work typically costs

Our collision repair cost guides break down what each repair should cost — dent repair, scratches, bumpers, hail damage, and paint work — including what drives the price and when an insurance claim beats paying cash. Knowing the going rate before you call makes it far easier to judge whether an estimate in Pine Island is fair.

Getting an estimate

For body and cosmetic damage, eligible shop pages offer a $4.99 preliminary photo report. This is not a mechanical diagnosis or a quote for tires, transmissions or drivetrain work. For those services, contact the business about an inspection and written estimate. Any preliminary bodywork figure also needs confirmation by the shop.