Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint
Auto parts store · Ithaca, New York
Get Your Preliminary Repair Estimate
Snap a few photos of the damage and get a preliminary report in about a minute for a one-time $14.99 payment. We'll share your request with Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint — if they're unavailable, we'll help connect you with another top-rated shop nearby.
Estimate requests are handled by AutoRepairEstimate.ai and shared with the shop — not submitted to Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint directly.
Own Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint? This listing is free to claim — see what you get.
See owner benefitsAbout Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint
Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint is listed at 358 Elmira Rd in Ithaca, New York under the category Auto parts store. That category does not include collision or body work — it appears in this directory because its listing sits among the Ithaca shops, so check before assuming it takes repair jobs. It is one of 35 listings we cover in Ithaca.
Customers rate it 5.0 out of 5 across 5 Google reviews. That is 0.7 of a star above the 4.3-star average across the 32 rated shops in Ithaca. The average shop we list in Ithaca carries 156 reviews, so this is a comparatively lightly reviewed listing.
Listed payment methods are checks, credit cards, debit cards and NFC mobile payments.
What's around this address
The three closest shops we list are all within a mile of this address, the nearest being Bruce's Pit Stop at 0.2 miles — comparing quotes here costs little more than a short walk.
When you can drop a car at Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint
Read from this shop's published opening hours, compared with every other shop we list in Ithaca.
Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint publishes hours for 6 days a week — Monday to Saturday. Across the week the earliest it opens is 8 AM and the latest it closes is 5 PM. It lists Sunday as closed.
Saturday cover is worth noting: 15 of the 33 shops in Ithaca that publish hours open on Saturday, and Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint is one of them.
Services
What Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint is known for, based on its public listing.
What customers say
See all reviews on Google5 Google reviews
How Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint compares in Ithaca
Standing among the 35 auto body shops listed in Ithaca, from Google review data.
#28 of 35
by review volume in Ithaca
5.0★ vs 4.3★
this shop vs the Ithaca average
#1 of 32
by rating among rated shops in Ithaca
Nearby alternatives to Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint
The closest shops to Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint, straight-line distance from its address.
| Shop | Rating | Reviews | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto PaintThis shop | 5.0★ | 5 | — |
| Bruce's Pit StopIthaca, NY | 4.4★ | 189 | 0.2 mi |
| Walmart Auto Care CenterIthaca, NY | 3.0★ | 112 | 0.3 mi |
| Maguire Honda of IthacaIthaca, NY | 4.7★ | 1,370 | 0.4 mi |
Auto body shops in towns near Ithaca
Distance is to the closest listing in each town, measured from this shop's address.
Where to look beyond Ithaca — the nearest towns we cover, with how many shops each holds.
- Newfield, NY3 shops · nearest 4.3 miles
- Lansing, NY3 shops · nearest 7.8 miles
- Freeville, NY3 shops · nearest 9.6 miles
- Trumansburg, NY1 shop · nearest 10.5 miles
- Dryden, NY3 shops · nearest 11.7 miles
Frequently asked questions
How do I contact Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint?
What are Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint's opening hours?
Is Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint open on weekends?
What does Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint list its business as?
Does Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint have its own website?
More auto body shops in Ithaca
Turn your free listing into booked jobs
Your listing is free, forever, and the instant photo-estimate widget is already live on this page. Claim the listing to manage it; subscribe to get the requests sent straight to you.
Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint
Ithaca, New York
Claim Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint
Update your hours, photos, services and contact info, and earn a Verified badge. No charge to claim.
We'll verify ownership and get your listing set up
Claim the estimate requests
Capture the customer, vehicle, photos, and report; receive the complete lead by instant email; get every damaged part sourced; and earn a $10 Pro credit per completed, non-refunded report.
See the live demo →Month-to-month · no setup fee · cancel anytime
Claiming is always free. Customer reports cost $14.99 each; shop subscriptions are billed separately through AutoEstimatePro. Your listing here stays free forever.
This listing was compiled from publicly available business information, including Google Maps data. Ratings, review excerpts and photos are attributed to their original source and remain the property of their respective owners. AutoRepairEstimate.ai is not affiliated with Maguire Auto Parts and Maguire Auto Paint. Request a correction or removal.